The History They Left Out: Islam and Europe’s Forgotten Roots
From al-Andalus to Sicily, from medieval libraries to the universities of Europe, the Islamic world helped shape the continent’s intellectual and cultural development for centuries. Yet this history remains largely marginal in the collective European memory. Rediscovering it means restoring a missing part of Europe’s own identity.
Granada holds a memory that refuses to disappear. Among the streets of the old city, in its courtyards, architecture and the intricate decorations of the Alhambra, the legacy of al-Andalus continues to emerge from the stones. It is more than the memory of a vanished civilisation. It is evidence of a chapter in European history that still struggles to receive the recognition it deserves in the continent’s collective consciousness.
Islam did not arrive in Europe only through migration in recent decades. It has been part of the continent’s history for many centuries: in the Iberian Peninsula, Sicily and the Balkans, through governments, trade, intellectual exchange and relations between communities. For long periods, Muslims, Christians and Jews shared territories, cities, economic activities and intellectual traditions, although these societies were also marked by conflict, discrimination and persecution.
Yet when the origins of European culture are discussed, this legacy is often presented only in fragments. We hear about the translation of Greek philosophers, the development of medicine and mathematics, but the role played by scholars of the Islamic world in shaping this knowledge is not always fully acknowledged. The result is an incomplete historical memory, as though part of Europe’s own past had somehow become foreign to Europe itself.
Al-Andalus: A European civilisation
For centuries, extensive areas of what are now Spain and Portugal were governed by Muslim dynasties. Al-Andalus was neither a uniform society nor an idealised model without contradictions. It consisted of different societies, dynasties and territories, shaped by periods of intellectual development, political competition, coexistence and conflict.
Its historical importance, however, is undeniable. Its cities became centres of scientific, philosophical, artistic and commercial activity that contributed to the development of the Mediterranean world and Europe.
The Muslim presence was not limited to political or religious elites. The population included people of diverse origins, among them Muslims born in the Iberian Peninsula, converts to Islam and communities whose roots in the region extended across generations. They were not simply people who had arrived from the East. They were also Europeans, part of the societies and territories in which they lived.
The memory of this presence survives in architecture, place names, agricultural techniques, language and local traditions. It also survives in family histories passed down through generations. Following the Christian conquests, forced conversions and expulsions, many Muslim communities were compelled either to abandon the public practice of their faith or to leave the peninsula. The Moriscos, descendants of Muslims who had converted to Christianity, sometimes preserved their religious practices and memories in secret.
Their experience represents a painful chapter in European history: that of people who, despite having belonged to Iberian society for generations, were progressively deprived of the freedom to maintain their identity.
Literature also preserves traces of this history. In Miguel de Cervantes’ Don Quixote, the character Ricote is a Morisco forced into exile. Although he cannot be regarded as a direct historical account of all Morisco communities, he offers a literary perspective on the human consequences of expulsion and the fracture between belonging, identity and political power.
Islamic scholarship and the formation of European culture
The history of al-Andalus cannot be separated from the movement of knowledge across the Mediterranean. The contribution of scholars from the Islamic world to European culture went far beyond the translation of earlier works.
In mathematics, al-Khwārizmī contributed to the development of algebra and the systematisation of methods for solving equations. Through the Arabic scientific tradition, numerical knowledge originating in India spread throughout Europe, including the positional number system and the use of zero. This was not simply a passive process of transmission. Existing knowledge was reworked and developed, opening new possibilities for calculation and mathematical thought.
In philosophy, the translation of Greek works into Arabic, sometimes through Syriac versions, made it possible to preserve, study and reinterpret a substantial part of the ancient intellectual heritage. Avicenna, known in the Arabic world as Ibn Sīnā, and Averroes, or Ibn Rushd, developed original philosophical systems that would profoundly influence medieval European thought. Later translations from Arabic into Latin contributed to university debates on nature, the soul, knowledge and metaphysics.
Astronomy also experienced significant development. Scholars in the Islamic world reworked Greek, Persian and Indian knowledge, producing observations, astronomical tables and mathematical instruments. Religious requirements, including the lunar calendar, prayer times and determining the direction of Mecca, helped support research that demanded considerable precision.
In optics, Ibn al-Haytham, known in Europe as Alhazen, produced fundamental studies on light and vision. His work entered the European scientific tradition through the circulation and translation of texts.
In medicine and surgery, the work of al-Zahrāwī, known in Latin as Albucasis, stands as one of the most important examples of scientific production in al-Andalus. His treatises described surgical procedures and instruments and became part of the medical literature used in Europe. The translations of Constantine the African, active in the intellectual environment of Monte Cassino and Salerno, also helped circulate medical knowledge from Arabic-language sources.
This legacy extended beyond science. In agriculture, water management and land organisation, al-Andalus developed irrigation systems and practices that transformed the landscape. The Alhambra and the Generalife preserve extraordinary evidence of this heritage. Water was not merely a resource to be distributed; it became an architectural, sensory and symbolic element, integral to gardens and inhabited spaces.
The decorative arts also reveal the exchanges between the two shores of the Mediterranean. Lustreware ceramics, craft techniques and ornamental motifs circulated between the Islamic world and European territories. Hispano-Moresque productions contributed to the development of European ceramic traditions, while cities such as Venice became important centres of commercial and artistic exchange.
It is important to distinguish between what was invented, what was improved and what was transmitted. But one point is clear: European culture did not develop in isolation. It emerged from a long history of encounters, conflicts, translations and cultural exchange.
A history that extends beyond Spain
The Islamic presence in Europe did not end with al-Andalus. Sicily was also governed by Muslim dynasties and retains deep traces of that period. Its history reflects layers of cultural influence in which Greek, Roman, Byzantine, Arab, Norman and Latin traditions came together.
From the Iberian Peninsula to Sicily and the Balkans, the Islamic world helped shape the European landscape. These presences should not be treated as foreign interruptions in the continent’s history, but as part of a shared historical experience.
The history of Jewish communities in the Iberian Peninsula also requires a balanced perspective. Under Muslim rule, there were periods of significant cultural and intellectual flourishing, but there were also episodes of discrimination and persecution. Recognising the richness of these exchanges does not mean idealising the past. It means acknowledging its complexity.
European history is a history of relationships, not of sealed and separate civilisations. Its cities, languages and institutions are the result of centuries of encounters between different peoples.
Forgotten memory and the politics of identity
How, then, did Islam come to be portrayed so often as something foreign to Europe?
The reasons are numerous. Political and military conflicts, religious rivalries and the construction of national identities gradually helped establish opposing images. Islam was frequently represented as an external adversary, while the history of cultural exchange and mutual influence was pushed into the background.
This representation has not disappeared. In contemporary public debate, attention frequently focuses on religious symbols, the hijab and the supposed incompatibility between Islam and European societies. Issues such as employment, housing, education, economic insecurity and inequality often receive far less attention.
The problem is not the open discussion of religion or migration policy. In a democratic society, every tradition and institution must remain open to critical examination. The problem arises when an entire community is turned into a collective target and its right to belong is constantly questioned.
Within this climate, the educational, professional and political achievements of citizens with migrant backgrounds can even be portrayed as a form of conquest rather than participation in society. The presence of doctors, teachers, researchers and professionals of foreign origin is sometimes interpreted through identity-based assumptions, as though their contribution were a threat rather than an asset.
Fundamentalism and imperialism: Two forms of power
Reducing contemporary history to a conflict between Islam and the West simply reproduces a division that fails to explain the complexity of international conflicts.
A more useful approach is to examine the structures of power shaping international politics. On one side stands religious fundamentalism, when it seeks to impose an absolute order through an authoritarian interpretation of faith. On the other stands imperialism, when a powerful state extends its control over other peoples through military force, political domination or economic interests.
These are different phenomena, but in certain circumstances they can reinforce one another. Foreign intervention can provide extremist movements with arguments for recruitment; extremist violence can then be used to justify further military intervention and new forms of control. Within this cycle, civilian populations lose their homes, their loved ones, their security and their ability to determine their own future.
It is often the powerful who confront one another, while ordinary people pay the highest price.
In the face of the devastation in Gaza, as in the face of any serious violation of human rights, the credibility of European principles is measured by their practical application. Respect for human dignity cannot depend on the identity of the victims, political alliances or diplomatic convenience. Human rights must apply even when defending them challenges the interests of governments.
Likewise, economic insecurity and social uncertainty cannot automatically be blamed on immigration. Unemployment, the housing crisis and declining public services require an examination of economic decisions, institutional policies and structural inequalities. Identifying a group to blame may be politically convenient, but it does not address the underlying causes of these problems.
Europe must recognise its entire history
Standing before the Alhambra, the supposed opposition between Islam and Europe becomes even less convincing. These buildings do not tell the story of a civilisation foreign to the continent. They bear witness to a civilisation that lived in Europe, transformed its landscapes and contributed to the circulation of knowledge.
The stones of Granada preserve beauty, but also the memory of violence, expulsions and fractured identities. The same is true of many places in Spain, Portugal and Sicily, where names, buildings, techniques and traditions continue to bear witness to a presence that cannot be reduced to a marginal footnote.
This memory should not become a tool for idealising the past or replacing one historical opposition with another. Its purpose should be to help us understand that Europe has never been culturally uniform and that its identity has been shaped by relationships that were often difficult, but profoundly significant.
European Islam is not a contradiction. It is a historical reality, long before it became a contemporary political question. Muslims living in Europe today are not simply part of a debate about immigration. They are citizens, workers, students, professionals and families who participate in the life of the continent. Their presence does not erase European history; it belongs to a history that has included them for centuries.
Perhaps this is precisely the part of our collective memory that we have neglected: there is no authentic Europe on one side and an alien Islamic presence on the other. There is a more complex European history, in which Islam has played a role that cannot be erased without impoverishing our understanding of the continent itself.
This is not about choosing between Islam and Europe.
It is about giving Europe back its complete history.
Because a society that forgets part of its past eventually loses the ability to fully recognise its present.




Comments